Tuesday, September 26, 2017

"All Monsters Are Human"

             Have you joined the Cult? No, I do not mean the creepy clown cult that follows innocent families around as seen in the current season of American Horror Story.  I am referring to the extensive fan base of the hit TV show itself.  The national phenomenon is filled with thrilling suspense, award winning actors, and recognizable villains.  However, the layout of the show is extremely unusual in that each season appears unrelated to the previous one.  Behind this seemingly odd approach is the imaginative mind of producer and co-creator Ryan Murphy.


            The Indianapolis native was born to two book publishers, so story writing and fiction were basically a part of Murphy’s upbringing.  He graduated from Indiana University as a well-read and well-educated journalism major.  Murphy worked as a reporter for a while before moving on to the television industry.  Murphy’s earlier career successes include Popular, Nip/Tuck, and most notably Glee.  After finishing the upbeat sitcom about a high school glee club, he decided to turn his attention to something darker and more complicated.  This is when he teamed up with Brad Falchuk to create American Horror Story. Throughout his life, Murphy has always had a special love for horror films and the sensation of fear.  He is particularly passionate about Halloween, which is reflected in the Halloween specials of American Horror Story.
           
            The television show is unique in that each season tells a different story while still starring reoccurring actors and even recycling some characters in minor ways.  Murphy has attributed this unique formula to his desire to reinvent the structure of the common television series.  Murphy has indicated that, although the tales of each season vary, they are all somehow interconnected.  One popular hypothesis is that each season represents one of the Circles of Hell depicted in Dante’s Inferno.  If this theory holds true, Murphy is effectively marrying the familiar idea of the Circles of Hell with a new and contemporary presentation of a television show.

            For example, season one’s premise is “Murder House.”  It chronicles the story of a family who moves into a mysterious Los Angeles home and learns of the terrible fates of those who encountered it.  It is speculated that “Murder House” represents the First Circle of Hell, Limbo, because of the souls that seem to be tied to the House itself.  Similarly, the fourth season, “Freak Show,” follows a struggling circus named “Fräulein Elsa’s Cabinet of Curiosities,” where many characters are striving for individual fame and fortune.  Because of the prevalent selfishness and emphasis on materialism, this season embodies the Fourth Circle of Hell, Greed. So far, the other five seasons have followed in suit, reflecting one of the Circles of Hell while still telling a distinct story. 

            Murphy also incorporates notorious American criminals into the series, calling on viewers’ memories of the infamous individuals.  He adopts the malevolent personas into the show, hinting at their inspiration without explicitly identifying them.  They are written seamlessly into the storylines, becoming a part of American Horror Story.  Some of the most noteworthy fiends featured in the show are the Axeman of New Orleans, who remained anonymous and only spared those who played jazz music from their homes; John Wayne Gacy, the professional clown who abducted and killed approximately 33 young men in the Chicago area; Gwen Graham and Cathy Wood, two nurses who opened a nursing home and chose their victims based on their first initials, so they would spell out “MURDER;” and H.H. Holmes, the physician who built a hotel with secret passageways and gas chambers, specifically designed for torture. 

Through references to Dante’s Inferno and the hints at infamous American murders, American Horror Story focuses on the notion that human vices lead to downfall and destruction.  One of the television show’s main themes is that humans themselves are the sources of evil.  Murphy takes this recognizable notion, reinventing into an anthology series.  He is able to draw the audience in close to a humanized character, encouraging them to identify with a lonely sociopath or a hypocritical moralist.  However, the series’ unique format does not ensure any characters’ safety or happy endings.  American Horror Story is able to explore surprising, outrageous, and thought-provoking outcomes without regards to viewers’ attachments to specific characters, all thanks to Ryan Murphy’s creative mind.




Sources:

2 comments:

  1. I've only seen the first three seasons of AHS, but I definitely see the connections to Dante and real-life killers. Artistic adaptations of the deadly sins are nothing new, but I think you're right that Murphy does it in newer and more culturally relevant ways. He throws a lot of surprising material at us, but I love the synthesis of realistic and supernatural elements. Like you said, it creates a unique opportunity to expose the nasty parts of human nature and our behavior in extreme circumstances. I definitely want to watch the rest of the seasons now. THANKS, ANGELA.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I also appreciate the rise of the anthology format in modern television. In the same vain as American Horror Story, Fargo and True Detective are some of the best shows on television which also depart from the season by season character arc structure of television. What all of these shows do so well is to capture a particular feeling that permeates individual stories. True Detective captures the sense of physical as well as moral decay and rot of the American South, and Fargo explores humanities capacity for senseless violence. In these shows, just like American Horror Story, new ideas are explored each season and writers can explore outside of what is expected on television. I appreciate this as a movement because it attracts big name stars to those shows and allows television to surpass its previous label as "common entertainment" and sometimes to surpass the film industry in artistic expression.

    ReplyDelete

Note: Only a member of this blog may post a comment.